• Jan 22, 2026
  • 4 min read

Why I Moved Off WordPress, and When You Shouldn't

What I did in 2022, what I measured later, and what I’d tell myself now.

In 2022 I moved my own blog from WordPress to Hugo, a static site generator. Years later, helping with a small business website that ran on hosted WordPress, the same question came up for someone else. This time I measured it.

It started with one script

The business site wanted privacy-friendly web analytics: Umami, the same one I use, GDPR-friendly and with no cookie banner. That’s a single <script> tag.

On their hosted WordPress plan it couldn’t be added. Plugins needed a business subscription, and the theme didn’t allow custom scripts either. One line of HTML was behind a pricing tier.

That’s the real argument against hosted WordPress for a small site. It’s not that WordPress is bad. It’s that you rent control of your own HTML.

What I measured

Response time. An uptime monitor (Uptime Kuma) checking the HTTP response, not just ping, showed the hosted WordPress and Wix sites I tested at roughly 500 ms per request. Static sites on a CDN typically answer in around 100 ms. Ping times looked similar; the gap was the server building the page on every request.

Uptime Kuma: wordpress.com averaging 556 ms per HTTP response

PageSpeed. Google PageSpeed Insights scored the WordPress theme noticeably lower, especially on mobile, where it matters most.

Weight. A carbon calculator (websitecarbon.com) made the same point a different way: more work per page view means more energy per visit.

None of this is a WordPress law of nature. A well-tuned WordPress with caching can be fast. A typical small-business setup, with a heavy theme and a stack of plugins, isn’t.

How a migration actually goes

  1. Inventory first. Fetch the sitemap (/sitemap.xml, or find it in robots.txt) to get every URL that exists today.
  2. Export the content. The WordPress export, or a scraper for hosted plans that limit it, then convert posts to Markdown. Tools and an LLM help with the conversion; the text should stay the author’s own.
  3. Keep the URLs, or redirect them. Search engines and old links know the current addresses. Either keep the same paths or add a 301 for each one.
  4. Check links before and after. LinkChecker (it runs as a container) crawls a site and lists every broken link.
  5. Pick a theme that fits the content, not the other way round. A photo site, a blog and a business landing page want different themes.
  6. Host it for free. Cloudflare Pages, GitHub Pages and Firebase Hosting all serve static sites with HTTPS at no cost.
  7. Add what you were missing. Analytics, forms, diagrams: on a static site each one is your own file.

The honest downside

Editing. On WordPress, the owner logs in and types. On a static site, content is Markdown in a Git repository. For me that’s a feature. For a non-technical owner it’s friction.

There are fixes: a browser-based editor (VS Code in the browser, GitHub’s web editor), or a Git-based CMS on top of the static site that gives a familiar editing screen. But it’s a real cost, and it’s the reason I don’t recommend migrating everyone.

When to stay on WordPress

  • Several non-technical people edit the site every day.
  • It depends on plugins with no static equivalent: a shop, bookings, memberships, learning platforms.
  • Nobody will maintain a build pipeline, however small.

When to move

  • The site changes a few times a month or less.
  • Speed, SEO or hosting cost matter.
  • You keep hitting “that needs a higher plan” for basic things.
  • You want to own your files and leave the host whenever you like.

My own blog has been static since 2022, and this site is static too. The thing I’d tell my 2022 self: moving the content is the easy part; the editing workflow is the real decision.

Takeaways

  • Measure HTTP response time, not ping. That’s where the difference shows.
  • Inventory URLs and redirect before you switch, or you lose your search traffic.
  • Static hosting is free; your time on editing isn’t.
  • Stay on WordPress if the people editing need it. Move if you need control.