• Oct 27, 2026
  • 3 min read

In Cold Email, Sending Capacity Runs Out Before Leads Do

My first instinct after the first Sunday review was “build a bigger list”. The send logs said otherwise: the list wasn’t the limit. The inboxes were.

The arithmetic

The sending side is two inboxes on a separate domain, warmed up for months. A safe pace for real (not warm-up) email is 10–15 a day per inbox, so:

2 inboxes × 15 emails/day = 30 emails/day

Every lead costs two emails: the first one and, if there’s no reply, one follow-up a few days later. Once a campaign is running, half of each day’s 30 sends are follow-ups to earlier leads. So the steady state is:

new leads per day = daily emails / (1 + follow-ups per lead)
                  = 30 / 2 = 15

15 new companies a day, 75 a week. Anything above that waits.

What happened when I ignored it

In week two I loaded 51 new leads at 20 a day, while the previous batch’s follow-ups were still due. The send logs:

DaySent
Monday30 (cap)
Tuesday30 (cap)
Wednesday30 (cap)
Thursdaywell under the cap
Fridaywell under the cap

Monday to Wednesday the cap was full and about 50 sends slipped to later days; by Thursday the queue had drained. Nothing broke, since the tool just queues, but follow-ups landed later than planned and the week’s capacity was used unevenly.

How I size a batch now

  1. Daily new leads = (inboxes × per-inbox cap) ÷ 2. With two inboxes, 15.
  2. Weekly batch ≈ 5 × daily new leads. 75 for one week; a 125-lead batch is one campaign that runs about eight working days.
  3. One campaign at a time when possible. Two overlapping campaigns compete for the same inboxes, and the older one’s follow-ups always win the queue.
  4. More capacity means another warmed inbox, not a higher cap. A third inbox takes the daily limit to 45 (22 new leads a day).

What it costs, per email and per lead

MonthlyPer unit at full use
Sending tool + inboxes~$80~$0.13 per email (≈ 630 emails/month)
Listings (maps scrape)~$5~$0.035 per usable lead

Data is the cheap part. A lead costs about a quarter of what it costs to email it twice. That changes what’s worth optimising: not “more leads per dollar of scraping”, but more replies per email sent.

Takeaways

  • Each lead costs two sends. Daily new leads are half the daily cap.
  • Size the batch to the inboxes, then fill it with the best leads, not the most.
  • Don’t overlap campaigns if you can avoid it.
  • Optimise replies per email, because the email is the expensive part.