- Oct 28, 2026
- 4 min read
880 Listings, 125 Leads: Where a Compliant B2B List Shrinks
For this week’s batch in the weekly loop I spent a full month’s scrape allowance at once: four trades in four cities, 55 listings each, 880 listings for about $4.40. It produced 125 leads. My first reaction was the same as yours: that’s it?
Stage by stage
| Stage | Left | Lost | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Map listings | 880 | ||
| Email on the business’s own website | 439 | 441 | No website, a contact form only, or a free-mail address |
| Active limited company / LLP / PLC | 259 | 180 | Sole traders and partnerships |
| Audit found something worth saying | ~248 | ~15 | The site is fine |
| Batch rules | 140 | 108 | See below |
| Read by a person | 125 | 15 | Wrong trade |
The two big drops are on purpose
Half the listings have no usable email. I only use an address the business publishes on its own website (how it’s found). Guessed addresses bounce; addresses scraped from directories are harder to defend under a legitimate interest assessment. A contact form is not an invitation to automate.
180 aren’t companies. In the UK, sole traders and most partnerships count as individual subscribers under PECR, so cold email to them needs prior consent. Limited companies don’t (the legal background). This filter is what makes the whole thing lawful. It stays, whatever it costs.
The batch rules, and the ones I’m tempted to loosen
| Rule | Held back | Keep it? |
|---|---|---|
| Name-only register match, registered office in another area | 32 | Yes: some are genuine (many small firms register at their accountant’s address), but this is exactly how you email the wrong company (why) |
| Load time under 6 s on re-check | 26 | Yes, for now: “your site takes 4.5 seconds” is a weak opener while I’m still testing whether anyone replies at all |
| Weak finding (only a missing share preview, etc.) | 25 | Yes |
| Same business twice (listed in two categories) | 12 | Obviously |
| Dissolved or inactive company | 5 | Obviously |
| Security finding no longer reproducible | 5 | Yes: fixed is fixed |
| Wrong inbox (careers@, accounts@) | 2 | Yes |
And then the human pass removed 15 that the rules couldn’t: surveyors and engineers returned for a design trade, a supplier and a showroom for a services trade, a recruitment firm for a professional one. Map categories are generous.
The lever that does move it: which trade
Usable leads per 100 listings, same rules, same week:
| Trade | Leads per 100 listings |
|---|---|
| Best | ~23 |
| Second | ~17 |
| Third | ~9 |
| Weakest | ~8 |
(An earlier batch had a trade at ~6.) The difference is almost all in the first two stages: some trades run as limited companies with their own website and a published address; others are mostly sole traders with a social page. Pick trades by how they’re structured, not by how big the market looks.
Is 14% bad?
At ~$0.035 per usable lead, no. As the previous post worked out, sending each lead costs more than finding it, and 125 leads already fill the inboxes for more than a week. Nothing was wasted, either: the listings that didn’t qualify stay in the raw layer for 90 days, so the same cities are never paid for twice.
Takeaways
- Most of the drop is the law and your own standards working.
- Keep the rules that protect you from emailing the wrong company.
- Read every row before it goes out. Categories lie.
- Choose trades by structure: limited companies with their own site.